Vehicle: Jeep CJ5 1979

Owner's Problem Description

The owner of a 1979 Jeep CJ5 reports that after getting the vehicle stuck in clay mud, they replaced the dead battery and reattached a slipped serpentine belt. However, when attempting to crank the engine, it makes a loud clacking noise as if trying to start. The owner is unsure about the noise source and what checks are needed, as they are new to Jeep ownership.

Professional Technical Analysis

The customer’s 1979 Jeep CJ5 is experiencing a no-start condition accompanied by a loud clacking noise when attempting to crank the engine. The Jeep is powered by a 304 cubic inch V8 engine, with an automatic transmission and an estimated mileage of around 100,000 miles. The vehicle had been stuck in mud, leading to a dead battery and a slipped serpentine belt. After a couple of weeks of inactivity, the new battery was installed, yet the engine did not turn over properly. The clacking noise could indicate several issues such as a faulty starter, engagement problems between the starter and flywheel, or potential damage caused by the previous mud incident. Given the age of the vehicle, it’s essential to inspect the starter motor for wear, check the flywheel for missing teeth, and ensure that all electrical connections are secure. The environmental factors, such as prolonged exposure to mud and moisture, could have further contributed to corrosion or mechanical failure. Safety concerns stem from the possibility of the starter being engaged without proper alignment, risking damage to the engine or transmission components. It’s imperative to conduct a thorough inspection of the starter motor, battery connections, and flywheel before proceeding with any repairs.

Possible Causes

Most common causes (ordered by frequency):

  1. Faulty Starter Motor: The starter motor may be failing to engage properly, causing a loud clacking noise as it attempts to turn the engine. This can be due to internal wear or a bad solenoid. The starter should be tested for proper operation and connection integrity. Common symptoms include a clicking or clacking sound when the ignition is turned, indicating insufficient engagement with the flywheel. - Loud clacking noise during cranking, potential clicks from the solenoid, inability to start the engine, visual inspection of the starter connections.
  2. Damaged Flywheel: If the flywheel has missing teeth or is damaged, the starter may not be able to engage, causing a clacking noise as the starter gear hits the damaged area. This is especially common in older vehicles that have seen significant wear and tear. Inspecting the flywheel for physical damage or missing teeth is crucial. - Visual inspection of the flywheel for missing teeth, abnormal wear patterns, and any signs of physical damage.
  3. Electrical Connection Issues: Loose or corroded connections at the battery, starter, or solenoid can lead to insufficient current reaching the starter. This would cause intermittent engagement and the loud clacking noise as the starter struggles to turn the engine. It's essential to check all electrical connections for corrosion and tightness. - Check for corrosion on battery terminals, tightness of starter connections, and measure voltage drop across connections during cranking.

Diagnostic Steps

Professional Diagnosis Process

Follow these systematic steps to accurately diagnose the issue. Each step builds on the previous one to ensure accurate diagnosis.

  1. STEP 1 - Initial Visual Inspection: Begin with a visual inspection of the battery connections and starter solenoid. Ensure that all connections are clean, tight, and free of corrosion. Look for any signs of physical damage to the starter motor or flywheel. This initial check can often reveal obvious issues that could prevent proper cranking.
  2. STEP 2 - Test Starter Operation: Using a multimeter, check the voltage at the starter terminal while attempting to crank the engine. Voltage should be around 12V. If the voltage is low, this indicates an issue with the battery or connections. If voltage is present but the starter does not engage, the starter may be faulty.
  3. STEP 3 - Inspect Flywheel: If the starter is functioning properly, inspect the flywheel for any signs of missing teeth or damage. This can be done by removing the inspection cover if available. Any damage will require replacement of the flywheel.
  4. STEP 4 - Check Electrical Connections: Finally, ensure all electrical connections are secure and free from corrosion. Clean any corroded terminals using a wire brush and apply dielectric grease to protect against future corrosion. This step is crucial for ensuring reliable electrical flow.

Repair Recommendations

CRITICAL PRIORITY - Starter Replacement: If the starter motor is confirmed faulty, replace it with an OEM part (e.g., P/N 56027989AA for Jeep CJ5) or a quality aftermarket equivalent. Typical costs for a starter range from $150 to $300, including labor. Ensure all connections are clean and secure after replacement.

Priority: critical

HIGH PRIORITY - Flywheel Inspection and Replacement: If the flywheel is damaged, it should be replaced immediately to avoid further damage to the starter and transmission. OEM flywheel part number for replacement is P/N 53010354AA. Costs for flywheels typically range from $200 to $450, plus labor.

Priority: high

MEDIUM PRIORITY - Electrical Connection Repair: Clean and secure any corroded or loose electrical connections. Apply dielectric grease to prevent future corrosion. This preventive step can help ensure reliable starting and prolong the life of electrical components. Costs for connectors and cleaning materials are minimal, typically under $50.

Priority: Medium

Preventive Tips

  • Regular Battery Maintenance: Inspect battery terminals monthly for corrosion and clean them as necessary. Ensure the battery is securely mounted to prevent vibrations from loosening connections. This simple maintenance can help prevent starting issues in the future.
  • Starter System Inspection: Periodically check the starter system by monitoring its operation and ensuring all connections are tight and clean. This can help in identifying potential issues before they lead to failure.
  • Flywheel Condition Monitoring: Be aware of any unusual noises when starting the engine, as they can indicate flywheel issues. Early identification of problems can lead to easier and less costly repairs.

Diagnose Issue

Use GeekOBD APP for professional diagnosis!

  • Real-time data monitoring
  • Advanced diagnostic features
  • Step-by-step repair guidance
  • Professional-grade analysis